×
  • remind me tomorrow
  • remind me next week
  • never remind me
Subscribe to the ANN Newsletter • Wake up every Sunday to a curated list of ANN's most interesting posts of the week. read more

Review

by Kim Morrissy,

Given (Movie)

Synopsis:
Given (Movie)
The seasons change, and with it comes a new opportunity for the band. As Mafuyu attempts to write a new song for the audition for an upcoming music festival, he learns about the complicated relationship between Akihiko and his ex-boyfriend Ugetsu. The two still live together and are unable to fully move past each other. Meanwhile, Haruki harbors unrequited feelings for Akihiko.
Review:

This approximately 60-minute film is a direct continuation of the TV series, although the focus is less on the main characters and more on the supporting band members Akihiko and Haruki. Even after the story moves on from Mafuyu's struggle to come to terms with the death of his first boyfriend, the themes of this anime remain consistent: This is an ordinary tale at heart about young men moving on and finding new love while cherishing what their past relationships have given them.

There are a few reasons why this arc does not quite reach the emotional heights of the TV series. The shorter length of the film, which corresponds to around three episodes of a TV anime, means that the story lacks the meticulous feeling of buildup to its climax that the series had. Also, there's less pathos in a messy breakup compared to the finality of death. I wouldn't consider the latter to be a flaw, though, because there's a sense of groundedness to the relationships depicted here that you wouldn't find in a tragic love story about a young couple separated by an untimely death. That said, if you go into this film expecting it to continue exploring Mafuyu's grief directly, you may come out underwhelmed.

It's also worth noting that, perhaps because this arc is about the relationship between adults, it does explore some more adult territory. It's not as explicit as Blue Lynx's previous offering, Twittering Birds Never Fly: The Clouds Gather, but there is an attempted sex scene which is more graphic than anything shown in the TV series. It's also non-consensual in nature, which may make some viewers uncomfortable even if the consequences of it are addressed within the narrative. It's one of those moments that makes you realize that Given isn't just about cute and fluffy first love or teenage angst; there are some murkier aspects of romantic relationships being explored here.

As you may expect, Mafuyu and Ritsuka somewhat fade into the background in this film, but the role that Mafuyu plays is pretty interesting. In the climax of the TV series, his song was a raw expression of his own grief, but as he grows as a musician he becomes able to express the feelings of other people through his lyrics. He becomes an observer to the dynamics between Akihiko, Ugetsu, and Haruki, and shows that he's very sensitive to their feelings. He's the ideal kind of supporting character in this context, because his journey as a musician complements the role he plays as a conveyor of emotions. That said, I will admit that I found it a bit voyeuristic of him to write a song about relationship drama that he's not a part of.

Speaking of songs, the music in this film is just as solid as the TV series. The rock ballad in the climax hits a lot of similar notes to its counterpart in that iconic scene from episode 9, meaning that it's an instant ear worm with some haunting lyrics. The CG in the performance scene still looks a bit awkward, but the editing mitigates this problem significantly by never lingering on a single shot for very long. Also, shout out to Tchaikovsky and Brahms for getting their pieces performed in this film! The bread and butter of this series may be rock music, but the classical violin performances are also important to the characters, and I really liked how this film was able to portray both Ugetsu and Akihiko as skilled violinists who nevertheless produce very different sounds.

Really, the only significant problem with this film is that it is too short. All the essential plot points do get represented, but the pacing feels a little abrupt, especially when it comes to portraying the passage of time. Aside from cues in the dialogue itself, it's hard to get a sense of just how long Akihiko and Haruki spend cohabiting, for instance. A film was never going to capture that slow and gradual sense of buildup that the TV series had, but I think this film could have benefited from having at least another twenty minutes of runtime to set the scene. Also, I really would have liked to see more of Mafuyu and Ritsuka's relationship, as it feels like Ritsuka essentially became a non-person in this arc. Even from an anime-only perspective I couldn't help but get the feeling that certain scenes were probably cut to make things fit the one-hour length.

Overall, I will say that I was satisfied with this continuation, even if I didn't like it quite as much as the original series. It's a given (heh) that fans of the series will be interested in this film, but if you haven't seen the TV anime yet, you owe it to yourself to check out one of the best BL anime series out there. Hopefully this film also makes it way to an English-speaking audience in some form.

Grade:
Overall : B
Story : B
Animation : B
Art : B
Music : B+

+ Direct continuation of the TV anime's plot and themes, explores a variety of relationship dynamics, great music performances
Attempted sexual assault scene may upset some viewers, pacing sometimes feels rushed

discuss this in the forum (3 posts) |
bookmark/share with: short url

this article has been modified since it was originally posted; see change history

Add this anime to
Production Info:
Director: Hikaru Yamaguchi
Screenplay: Yuniko Ayana
Storyboard:
Hitomi Ezoe
Yōko Kanamori
Hikaru Yamaguchi
Unit Director:
Hitomi Ezoe
Yōko Kanamori
Mana Uchiyama
Hikaru Yamaguchi
Music: MICHIRU
Original creator: Natsuki Kizu
Character Design: Mina Ōsawa
Art Director:
Ayano Okamoto
Tatsurō Ōnishi
Chief Animation Director:
Hina Nagata
Nanako Ninomiya
Animation Director:
Tomohito Hirose
Yusuke Kamata
Nozomi Kawano
Sang Min Kim
Katsusuke Konuma
Keiko Kurosawa
Yoshihiro Maeda
Ikuko Matsushita
Yūji Moriyama
Hina Nagata
Ryoko Oka
Sansai Onoki
Ma Kang Park
Peng Sun
Yasuho Tamura
Yue Chun Wang
Mayumi Watanabe
Jōji Yanase
Byoung Gil Yang
Sound Director: Hiromi Kikuta
Cgi Director: Tomoya Mizuno
Director of Photography: Naoki Serizawa
Executive producer:
Atsuhiro Iwakami
Shingo Kunieda
Kazuo Miura
Kyōichi Takeda
Ryū Utsui
Producer:
Miho Matsumoto
Yuka Okayasu
Licensed by: Crunchyroll

Full encyclopedia details about
Given (movie)

Review homepage / archives